More Frosting Please!

Wedding
Cakes
&
More

Plymouth, Wis.

More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis. More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis. More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis. More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis.



More Frosting Please!

Wedding
Cakes
&
More

Plymouth, Wis.

More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis. More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis. More Frosting Please! Wedding Cakes & More Plymouth, Wis.

920-550-9020

A gorgeous, on trend 'naked' wedding cake that More Frosting Please! provided for a local wedding.

Ordering and Serving Sizes

To schedule your free wedding cake consultation with Shelly, please email us at MFPcakes@gmail.com


Please keep in mind that we are already booking into 2023 with a few openings remaining in 2022.


The wedding cake is the center point of most wedding receptions. At most weddings, cutting the cake is considered one of the final traditions of the day, so important. that no one leaves the reception before the cake is cut. In fact, the wedding cake is one of the pivots of wedding photographs. There are many factors to be considered while choosing a wedding cake; however, the most critical factor is the size of it.


We require consultations to discuss the sizing, theme, decorations, dietary restrictions, flavors and fillings for each wedding cake.  At the consultation we will discuss your thoughts and ideas and come up with a plan to execute the perfect dessert for your perfect day.


Flavors and Fillings

* Almond Amaretto

* Cookies -n Cream

* French Vanilla

* Chocolate 

* Chocolate and Vanilla Marble  

* Chocolate Chip (white cake) 

* German Chocolate

* Salted Caramel
* Red Velvet 

* White or Lemon Poppy Seed 

* Lemon (Plain, raspberry or blueberry)
* Confetti

* Strawberry 

* Carrot 

WE DO NOT DO ANY FONDANT!  Sorry for the inconvenience.

Buttercream is the recommended icing for wedding cakes.


Fillings offer a great addition to any ordinary cake.  The fruit not only enhances the flavors, but also pleases a wider variety of your guests!  Cakes filled with additional icings or fudge can add another blast of flavor as well!


Fillings offered:

(Fresh Fruit does incur an additional charge of $8-$50 size dependant)

cherry

raspberry

strawberry

bavarian creme

fudge
pineapple

lemon chiffon

orange dreamsicle

peanut butter 

...and most anything else you can dream up!

Photo Gallery

Show More

Site Content

Wedding or Bridal Events

Wedding or Bridal Events

Wedding or Bridal Events

 At More Frosting Please we strive to make wedding cake planning a fun and stress free experience. Each couple meets with us to taste and also help design a delicious and beautiful wedding cake.  

"That cake was perfect."

Wedding or Bridal Events

Wedding or Bridal Events

 "I can't thank you enough! That cake was perfect and the flavor was off the charts! You are so talented!   We got so many compliments on our cake! You did exactly what I wanted and MORE!! You are AMAZING!! 

Celebration Cakes

Dietary Restrictions (yes, we do!)

Dietary Restrictions (yes, we do!)

While we love doing cakes to celebrate all occasions, we are currently only accepting orders for weddings. We appreciate your understanding.

Dietary Restrictions (yes, we do!)

Dietary Restrictions (yes, we do!)

Dietary Restrictions (yes, we do!)

In our world there are a growing number of people with food intolerances or allergies. We take this VERY seriously. We do offer gluten free, dairy free, egg free, nut free goodies by SPECIAL ORDER. However, we do operate out of a shared kitchen where common allergens are used. Please know that we do everything in our power to keep you and your loved ones safe. In fact-my SON has Celiac disease and is lactose intolerant.

About Us

Shelly

Hi! I'm the woman behind the magic! I began MFP in 2011 after battling stage 3 breast cancer. I now count my blessings to have a job that I love. It never feels like work!

What we're known for:

More Frosting Please! is a woman owned business started in and serving Plymouth Wi and surrounding counties. Delivery available for all contracted weddings. 

Contact Us

Looking for more information? Want to book a wedding cake consultation? Interested in knowing more about what else we offer? Please contact us below! Please allow up to 48 hours for a response. we get busy!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

More Frosting Please! Sweet Shoppe

Plymouth, Wisconsin 53073, United States

920.550.9020 MFPcakes@gmail.com

  • Home

More Frosting Please! Sweet Shoppe

PLYMOUTH, WI 53073

920-550-9020

Copyright © 2022 More Frosting Please! Sweet Shoppe - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by GoDaddy