Open Fridays 10am-5pm and Saturdays 10am-2pm
We now require all orders to be prepaid when placed online through our online ordering site here: https://mfp-orders.square.site Please don't be afraid to ask us questions!
Different Occasions call for different size slices. A cake for a child's birthday party will inevitably be sliced into smaller pieces. A gathering for your groomsmen to celebrate the upcoming nuptials will inevitably be sliced into larger pieces. Working together on the design, occasion and flavoring will lead to a successful event!
Mini cupcake-serves 1 child
Standard cupcake-serves 1 adult
Jumbo cupcake-serves 1-2 adults
8" Double layer round cake serves a minimum of 12
10" Double layer round cake serves a minimum of 20
12" Double layer round cake serves a minimum of 35
14" Double layer round cake serves a minimum of 50
Round cakes are to be cut differently than the typical 'pizza' cut: with round cakes you should cut in a circle shape about 2 inches in from the edge, then cut slices out of that. Then another circle inside of that and so on.
1/4 sheet Serves 15-20
1/2 sheet Serves 35-40
3/4 sheet Serves 50-65
FULL sheet Serves up to 80
(All sheet cakes can be done as a double layer as well, doubling each cakes serving amounts
Flavors of deliciousness:
* French Vanilla
* Chocolate and White Marble
* Light Chocolate
* Dark Chocolate
* Chocolate Chip (white cake)
* Chocolate Mint
* Red Velvet
* White or Lemon Poppy Seed
* Strawberry Cake
WE DO NOT DO ANY FONDANT! Sorry for the inconvenience.
Buttercream (Typical Wedding Cake Icing)
Whipped Icing (Not as sweet, more light and fluffy)
Fillings offer a great addition to any ordinary cake. The fruit not only enhances the flavors, but also pleases a wider variety of your guests! Cakes filled with additional icings or fudge can add another blast of flavor as well!
(Fresh Fruit does incur an additional charge of $3-24 size dependant)
...and most anything else you can dream up!
At More Frosting Please we strive to make wedding cake planning a fun and stress free experience. Each couple meets with us to taste and also help design a delicious and beautiful wedding cake.
Celebrating all of the big milestones in your life is what we live for! Whether it is birthday related, job related or goal oriented....we would love to help you celebrate it!
"I can't thank you enough! That cake was perfect and the flavor was off the charts! You are so talented! We got so many compliments on our cake! You did exactly what I wanted and MORE!! You are AMAZING!!
We are currently operating only part time and will be open FRIDAYS 10-5pm and SATURDAYS 10am-2pm. We look forward to seeing you!!
Who doesn't enjoy celebrating the wonderful Littles in our lives?! The joy, the excitement, the happiness...birthdays are just magical when we are kids, aren't they? We can help you celebrate your kiddo's special day with a creation geared towards what they love!
In our world there are a growing number of people with food intolerances or allergies. We take this VERY seriously. We do offer gluten free, dairy free, egg free, nut free goodies by SPECIAL ORDER. However we do operate out of a shared kitchen where common allergens are used. Please know that we do everything in our power to keep you and your loved ones safe. In fact-my SON has Celiac disease and is lactose intolerant....and my one daughter can not handle sucrose. Not fun.
Hi! I'm the woman behind the magic! I began MFP in 2011 after battling stage 3 breast cancer. I now count my blessings to have a job that I love. It never feels like work!
It's hard to imagine but we have made over 40,000 cakes in the past 10 years!!!!!!!
Stop in at More Frosting Please to try some of the many flavors we offer each week. We truly do everything we can to be the best!
*** We have reopened! We are operating only part time and will be open FRIDAYS 10-5pm and SATURDAYS 10am-2pm. We look forward to seeing you!!
More Frosting Please! is a family owned business in Plymouth, WI. We are not only a storefront shop where you can come in to purchase desserts-but we also offer classes, contests, and create special order cakes, cupcakes, cookies, peanut squares and more.
Hello! Thank you for reaching out to More Frosting Please! We are currently operating only part time and will be open FRIDAYS 10-5pm and SATURDAYS 10am-2pm. We look forward to seeing you!!
125 E. MILL ST, PLYMOUTH, WI 53073